When Anna Hewson’s daughter’s iPhone disappeared one weekend, she did what any parent would do — she followed the digital crumbs.

Using Apple’s “Find My” app, the KUSA 9News producer tracked the stolen device until it ended up at a Walmart in Arvada, Colorado.

Inside the store stood an EcoATM, a kiosk that pays cash for used phones. Hewson had a hunch, so she called the police. Moments later, officers unlocked the machine with help from EcoATM’s customer service. Inside the bin sat a pile of locked phones, including her daughter’s.

Don’t miss

“At face value, the idea that you can walk in and turn over, sell stolen property to a machine, it seems like the perfect vehicle to further your crime,” Arvada Police Department Public Information Officer Chase Amos told 9News.

What are EcoATMs?

EcoATMs are automated kiosks found at major retailers, including Walmart. They offer users instant cash in exchange for used electronics.

The machines scan a seller’s ID, take a thumb print, snap a photo and send the data to live agents for verification. Devices are held for at least 30 days at a processing center in Louisville, Kentucky, which offers a short window where owners can recover stolen property.

EcoATM claims to work closely with law enforcement, logging device serial numbers in national databases and cooperating with investigations.

“EcoATM happily and voluntarily cooperates with law enforcement when requested. If a missing phone does end up in one of our machines, it is returned to the rightful owner,” a company spokesperson told 9News.

Still, theft victims say recovery isn’t always so simple.

Despite robust security measures, the high volume of stolen phones and the anonymity offered by kiosks make investigations challenging for law enforcement.

Read more: Want an extra $1,300,000 when you retire? Dave Ramsey says this 7-step plan ‘works every single time’ to kill debt, get rich in America — and that ‘anyone’ can do it

Frustrating search for a stolen phone

Michael Dill, a Denver veteran, told 9News that he was mugged on St. Patrick’s Day in 2024. Hours later, he tracked his phone to an EcoATM in an Englewood Walmart. Though he reported it, Dill said he spent weeks in a frustrating loop trying to confirm the phone’s presence at EcoATM’s warehouse.

Eventually, the company sent him a replacement device. But, he says his old phone later resurfaced in the hands of someone with a UK phone number who texted him and demanded he remove the device from Apple’s security system. When Dill refused, the texter threatened to access his data.

He contacted Apple, which assured him the phone would remain locked and his data would remain secure.

In a statement to 9News, EcoATM said Dill’s phone was not found among any devices in its warehouse.

“Because we were unable to locate Michael’s phone, we were unable to return it to him,” a spokesperson said. “However, we did in good faith, provide him with a complimentary replacement device.”

Protecting yourself devices

On the bright side, there are several ways to help protect yourself from scams involving services like EcoATM.

If your device is stolen, report it to your local police department. If you do track it to an EcoATM kiosk, notify the company via their customer service line. But, authorities warn people should never try to go out and find the phone on their own.

What to read next

Like what you read? Join 200,000+ readers and get the best of Moneywise straight to your inbox every week. Subscribe for free.

This article provides information only and should not be construed as advice. It is provided without warranty of any kind.