Plans to replace the Sagamore Bridge, a major access point to Cape Cod, have sparked controversy as several homeowners face losing their properties to eminent domain.

While many local drivers welcome the infrastructure improvements, affected residents are struggling with uncertainty about compensation, relocation and the impact on property values.

Don’t miss

Marc and Joan Hendel, who had recently moved to Sagamore’s Round Hill community, were devastated to learn that their home could be taken as part of the project.

“This is heartbreaking to us that they’re just coldly giving us a letter that says we’re going to destroy your home,” Marc told CBS Boston in a March interview.

The Massachusetts Department of Transportation (MassDOT) plans to replace the aging Sagamore Bridge as part of a broader effort to improve Cape Cod’s infrastructure. The project, which also includes replacing the Bourne Bridge, is expected to take years to complete.

A total of $1.72 billion in federal funding has been secured for the Sagamore Bridge. In a statement released in July 2024, coinciding with the announcement of a major funding award.

“This is a game-changing award for Massachusetts,” Massachusetts Governor Maura Healy proclaimed. “We’ve never been closer to rebuilding the Cape Cod Bridges than we are right now. This funding will be critical for getting shovels in the ground.”

The government may acquire nearby homes as part of the project, leaving some residents uncertain about their future. The final list of affected properties has yet to be released, but the uncertainty has already disrupted the local real estate market. Many are now weighing their options, deciding whether to sell, hold out for a buyout or challenge the process.

How eminent domain affects home values and market stability

Eminent domain, the government’s legal right to seize private property for public use, can significantly influence home values.

When a government entity signals its intent to take properties for a project, the uncertainty can cause hesitation among buyers, leading to decreased property demand and, ultimately, lower home values in affected communities.

Read more: Want an extra $1,300,000 when you retire? Dave Ramsey says this 7-step plan ‘works every single time’ to kill debt, get rich in America — and that ‘anyone’ can do it

In some cases, properties near eminent domain projects lose value even if they’re not directly taken. The potential for construction disruptions, increased traffic and changes in the area may make potential buyers think twice. Since the Sagamore Bridge project is part of a multi-phase project that could take years to complete, market instability in the area may persist.

What homeowners can do about eminent domain

For homeowners who may be impacted by eminent domain, there are steps to take to ensure fair treatment and compensation:

Consult an eminent domain attorney: A real estate lawyer specializing in eminent domain can help homeowners understand their rights and negotiate a fair settlement.

Get an independent appraisal: The government is required to offer just compensation, but independent property valuations can help ensure you receive an appropriate offer. Eminent domain valuation can be complex, and you may not have a second chance if you don’t like the results of your appraisal. Work with an eminent domain lawyer to ensure you get the right type of appraisal.

Negotiate for better terms: Homeowners may be able to contest the initial compensation offer or request relocation assistance depending on state laws and project funding.

Stay informed: Attend community meetings to stay updated on project timelines so you can make informed decisions about your property.

The Sagamore Bridge project highlights the complexities of eminent domain, a process that affects homeowners nationwide. Whether facing a bridge replacement or another public development, property owners must navigate legal and financial challenges.

If you find yourself in a situation similar to these Cape Cod homeowners, stay informed and seek expert guidance to help navigate the process and protect your interests.

What to read next

This article provides information only and should not be construed as advice. It is provided without warranty of any kind.

Related Posts

Got $2 million? Here's how long that...
A record number of people are reaching retirement age. Each...
Read more
'I'm powerless': New Jersey family left in...
Kira Traore says she was paying exactly zero dollars in...
Read more
'He deserves every penny': California homeless man...
A homeless man in San Luis Obispo, California, has gone...
Read more